Blog details

It’s Official: Radioactive Isotope Dating Is Fallible The Institute For Creation Research

Depending on design, this process can contribute some one to ten percent of all fission reactions in a reactor, but too few of the average 2.5 neutrons produced in each fission have enough speed to continue a chain reaction. Furthermore, the formation of igneous and metamorphosed rocks involves melting, crystallization, and/or recrystallization of minerals, which could cause the distributions of the various elements and their isotopes to be altered. So, there is no guarantee that all the atoms of U, Th, and Pb isotopes in the source rocks will be transferred into the new rocks that form and their constituent minerals. It is basically impossible to quantify the amount of isotopic mixing, extraction, and fractionation in mantle and crustal isotopic reservoirs at each stage, which then impacts the assumed Pb isotopic evolution in the next stage.

Depleted uranium is preferred over similarly dense metals due to its ability to be easily machined and cast as well as its relatively low cost. The main risk of exposure to depleted uranium is chemical poisoning by uranium oxide rather than radioactivity . Activity is the number of nuclear decays occurring in a radioactive source per time . The SI unit of activity is the becquerel , which is equal to an inverse second [1/s or s−1]. The becquerel is named in honor of the French scientist Henri Becquerel (1852–1908) who was the first person to detect radioactive decay.

Relative Abundance of the Radon Isotopes

Natural uranium and depleted uranium are α-emitters; depleted uranium is also a weak γ-emitter. 238U has the longest half-life of the three isotopes (4.5 billion years), making it the least radioactive isotope and the isotope most likely to cause chemical toxicosis rather than radiation injury. 238U is used for photographic intensifiers, ceramic colorants, dental porcelain additives, radiation shielding, military armor, and armor-piercing bullets. The main source of exposure to uranium is from mining and manufacturing of uranium products.

About Nature Portfolio

The gas radon-222 escapes from the ground and decays rapidly in the atmosphere to lead-210 , which falls quickly to the surface where it is incorporated in glacial ice and sedimentary materials. By assuming that the present deposition rate also prevailed in the past, the age of a given sample at depth can be estimated by the residual amount of lead-210. Laser ablation inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry (LA-ICP-MS)6 to date zircon is claimed not to usually require large common Pb corrections.

Ar-isotope techniques can date materials as young as several thousand to many millions of years. Dating a rock involves uranium-lead measurements on many zircons, then assessing the quality of the data. Some zircons are obviously disturbed and can be ignored, while other cases are harder to judge.

There’s never been a more important time to explain the facts, cherish evidence-based knowledge and to showcase the latest scientific, technological and engineering breakthroughs. Cosmos is published by The Royal Institution of Australia, a charity dedicated to connecting people with the world of science. Financial contributions, however big or small, help us provide access to trusted science information at a time when the world needs it most. Please support us by making a donation or purchasing a subscription today. This method is limited, because it’s only applicable to volcanic rocks, but is useful for older archaeology because it has a date range of about 4.3 billion to 100,000 years ago.

Argon is an inert substance, which means that it basically will not combine chemically with other elements. It is also a gas over a wide range of temperatures, which means that any 40Ar would escape while the rock was molten like carbon dioxide escaping from a glass of soda. After solidification, those 40Ar nuclei that appeared as a result of radioactive decay would be trapped by the crystal structure and accumulate as the mineral aged.


The isotopic distribution of carbon on the Earth is roughly 99% carbon 12 and 1% carbon 13 . These isotopes are stable, which is why they are with us today, but unstable isotopes are also present in minute amounts. About one carbon atom in a trillion contains a radioactive nucleus with 6 protons and 8 neutrons — carbon 14. Radiation, which is a byproduct of radioactive decay, causes electrons to dislodge from their normal position in atoms and become trapped in imperfections in the crystal structure of the material. Dating methods like thermoluminescence, optical stimulating luminescence and electron spin resonance, measure the accumulation of electrons in these imperfections, or “traps,” in the crystal structure of the material. If the amount of radiation to which an object is exposed remains constant, the amount of electrons trapped in the imperfections in the crystal structure of the material will be proportional to the age of the material.

In sufficient concentration, these isotopes maintain a sustained nuclear chain reaction. This generates the heat in nuclear power reactors, and produces the fissile material for nuclear weapons. Depleted uranium is used in kinetic energy penetrators and armor plating. Without a closed system, uranium-lead dating, like all other radiometric dating methods, falls apart. Assuming a closed system means that nothing on the outside of the rock affected the sample. This means that none of the parent or daughter isotope leaked in or out.

Current ratio of U235 in natural uranium is the same anywhere in the solar system. “The longer that object is buried, the more radiation it’s been exposed to,” Rittenour said. In essence, long-buried objects exposed to a lot of radiation will have a tremendous amount of electrons knocked out of place, which together will emit a bright light as they return to their atoms, she said. Therefore, the amount of luminescent signal tells scientists how long the object was buried. This article will summarize the points from the first technical paper of the series. Ale’s Stones at Kåseberga, around ten kilometres south east of Ystad, Sweden were dated at 56 CE using the carbon-14 method on organic material found at the site.

Undamaged zircon retains the lead generated by radioactive decay of uranium and thorium up to very high temperatures (about 900 °C), though accumulated radiation damage within zones of very high uranium can lower this temperature substantially. Zircon is very chemically inert and resistant to mechanical weathering – a mixed blessing for geochronologists, as zones or even whole crystals can survive melting of their parent rock with their original uranium–lead age intact. Thus, zircon crystals with prolonged and complicated histories can contain zones of dramatically different ages , and so are said to demonstrate “inherited characteristics”. Unraveling such complexities (which can also exist within other minerals, depending on their maximum lead-retention temperature) generally requires in situ micro-beam analysis using, for example, ion microprobe , or laser ICP-MS.

Years; it is the next most stable uranium isotope after 238U and is also predominantly an alpha emitter, decaying to thorium-231. Uranium-235 is important for both nuclear reactors and nuclear weapons, because it is the only uranium isotope existing in nature on Earth in any significant amount that is fissile. This means that it can be split into two or three fragments by thermal neutrons. The decay chain of 235U, which is called the actinium series, has 15 members and eventually decays into lead-207. The constant rates of decay in these decay series makes the comparison of the ratios of parent to daughter elements useful in radiometric dating.

Uranium metal is commonly handled with gloves as a sufficient precaution. Uranium concentrate is handled and contained so as to ensure that people do not inhale or ingest it. Triuranium octoxide and uranium dioxide are the two most common uranium oxides.

The dual decay of potassium to 40Ar and 40Ca was worked out between 1921 and 1942. Its great advantage is that most rocks contain potassium, usually locked up in feldspars, clays and amphiboles. However, potassium is very mobile during metamorphism and alteration, and so this technique is not used much for old rocks, but is useful for rocks of the Mesozoic and Cenozoic Eras, particularly unaltered igneous rocks. Below infographic summarizes the difference between carbon dating and uranium dating.